Fair Solitaire
Baker's Game
Every game can be won. We checked.
Game
#
Moves
0
Time
0:00

How to play Baker's Game

Baker's Game is FreeCell with one rule changed: in the columns you build down in the same suit, not in alternating colours. The 7 of hearts goes on the 8 of hearts and nowhere else. That one change makes about one deal in four impossible to win, and it is the reason this site exists. Every game you are dealt here can be won. New to the layout? Start with FreeCell.

What changes from FreeCell

The table, the free cells and the foundations are FreeCell's, and any card may still go into an empty column. Only the building rule differs, and that changes three things.

Why one deal in four cannot be won

A card whose one home is buried has to wait in a free cell or an empty column, and at the start there are four cells and no empty column. Picture the 9 of clubs lying above the 4 of clubs in the same column. The 4 cannot go up until the 9 moves, and the 9 can only go on the 10 of clubs. If the 10 is buried too, the 9 takes a cell. When too many cards must wait at once, the cells fill before a column comes free, and nothing can move. In FreeCell the 9 would have two 10s to choose from.

Our solver won 74,931 of the first 100,000 deals, 74.9%. The published study by Charlie Blake and Ian Gent, The Winnability of Klondike Solitaire and Many Other Patience Games, found 75.1% of Baker's Game deals winnable: a different method, different deals, and almost the same answer.

It is the rule, not the cards. Our solver played the 25,069 deals that cannot be won as Baker's Game again as FreeCell, with the same cards in the same places, and won 24,832 of them, 99%, giving up on the rest after 200,000 positions.

Why we built this site

Fair Solitaire began with a lot of FreeCell. We moved on to Baker's Game, kept losing, and in time found out why: one deal in four had no way through, however well we played. Most places deal those games anyway and say nothing. Here no deal reaches you until our solver has won it. The whole story.

The rules in brief

The FreeCell page explains the layout and the rule for moving runs in full.

How to play here

Tap or click a card and it goes to the best place: its foundation, the card one rank higher of its suit, an empty column, or a free cell, in that order. Tap a card inside a run to move the run from that card up. Drag a card to put it somewhere else.

Cards go up to the foundations by themselves, which in Baker's Game is always safe, so an Ace dealt on top of a column goes up before your first move. A card you drag back from a foundation stays in play until you send it up.

Undo takes back any number of moves, and Restart deals the same game again. Hint shows a good next move, or, after a wrong turn, offers to take you back to where the game can still be won.

Strategy for building by suit

What the opening layout predicts

Every card is face up, so a deal can be read before the first move. These are our solver's win rates on all 100,000 deals, grouped by the layout; overall it won 74.9%. The top card of a column is the one you can play; the bottom card lies under all the others.

Share of deals the solver won, by what the layout showed (all 100,000 deals)
In the opening layoutWon
No Ace on top of a column (50,033 deals)68.4%
Two Aces on top (9,736 deals)87.9%
8 cards or fewer on top of the four Aces (25,029 deals)86.7%
15 cards or more on top of the Aces (18,214 deals)60.4%
Two Aces at the bottom of a column (9,778 deals)64.6%
No top card fits on another top card (31,018 deals)66.3%
Three top cards fit on another (4,979 deals)89.5%
Two Kings on top of a column (9,796 deals)64.2%
Two Kings at the bottom of a column (9,769 deals)80.5%

The Aces matter most: 26 points separate the deals with 8 cards or fewer on top of the four Aces from those with 15 or more, and the average deal has 11. Each Ace showing adds about ten points, and each top card that fits on another, a move ready to make, adds about eight. Each King showing takes about eight away. Even the worst groups were won three times in five.

The numbers

Our solver won 74,931 of the first 100,000 deals. The game replayed every solution move by move, and New game deals only from that list. The first deal it could not win is number 10. The longest run of winnable deals is 39, from 29,319 to 29,357, and the longest run of deals with no way through is nine, from 98,492 to 98,500.

The solver gives up after 200,000 positions, so on its own a deal missing from the list proves nothing. But a Baker's Game deal with no way through turns out to be small: a typical one can reach fewer than 5,000 different positions, and the largest, deal 65,814, about 115,000. So we went back to all 25,069 deals the solver had not won and tried every position each one can reach. None had a way through. For the first 100,000 deals the list is exact: 74,931 can be won, and 25,069 cannot.

Its first 1,000 wins took a median of 38 moves, from 14 for game 852 to 87 for game 27. The solver does not look for the fewest moves, so you can often do better. Seahaven Towers and Eight Off build by suit too, with more room, and far more of their deals come out. The numbers for every game.

Game numbers

Every game has a number, and the same number always deals the same cards; the numbers are FreeCell's. Add a number to the address, for example #2, to play or share a game. A number with no known solution, such as 10, gives you a winnable game instead.

Frequently asked questions

Is Baker's Game harder than FreeCell?

Much harder. In FreeCell only eight of the first million deals cannot be won; in Baker's Game 25,069 of the first 100,000 cannot. Even a deal that can be won leaves you fewer choices, because each card has one home in the columns instead of two.

Why can't I put a red 7 on a black 8?

Because Baker's Game builds by suit, not by colour: the 7 of hearts goes only on the 8 of hearts. Alternating colours is the rule of FreeCell, which began as Baker's Game with exactly this rule changed.

Can every deal of Baker's Game be won?

No. Of the first 100,000 deals, 25,069 cannot be won however well you play: we tried every position each of them can reach. Here you are only dealt the other 74,931, so every game you play can be won.

Is game 7 the same as FreeCell game 7?

Yes. Both games use the same numbered shuffle, so a number gives the same cards in the same places. Only the building rule differs, so a deal that comes out as FreeCell can have no way through here; game 10 is the first. It works the other way too: FreeCell game 11982, which cannot be won, comes out as Baker's Game.

Who invented Baker's Game?

Its first inventor is not recorded. It is named after C. L. Baker, whose game Martin Gardner described in the Mathematical Games column of Scientific American in June 1968, tracing it back to an Englishman in the 1920s. The same column led Paul Alfille to try alternating colours instead, and that game became FreeCell.

Does the game tell me when I am stuck?

Yes. When no card can move at all, which here means all four free cells are full and nothing fits, a message says so and offers to find the move where it went wrong.