Which solitaire game should you play?
Every deal on this site has a known way through: our solver won it, or, for FreeCell, other solvers checked it years ago. The twelve games are still very different. Some are won in fewer than 40 moves and some take over 200. Some show you every card from the start; in others most of the cards are face down or waiting in the stock. In a few, the deal decides more than you do. Here is how they compare on our own numbers, and which one might suit you today.
The twelve games side by side
| Game | Can be won | Hidden cards | Moves in a win | In three words |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Klondike | 85.2% | Yes 21 face down | 84 average card moves | Classic, patient, forgiving |
| Klondike Turn 3 | 74.1% | Yes 21 face down | 85 card moves | Classic, but harder |
| Spider | 92.8% | Yes 44 face down | 108 card moves | Gentle long game |
| Spider 2 Suits | 84.5% | Yes 44 face down | 141 card moves | The middle step |
| Spider 4 Suits | 46.5% | Yes 44 face down | 208 card moves | Long expert test |
| FreeCell | 99.999% | No | 59 | Pure planning puzzle |
| Baker's Game | 74.9% | No | 38 | Strict suit puzzle |
| Seahaven Towers | 88.5% | No | 35 | Short, tight puzzle |
| Eight Off | 99.9% | No | 34 | Roomy, quick puzzle |
| Golf | 26.1% | Yes stock order | 51 | Short, hard, luck-heavy |
| Pyramid | 66.5% | Yes stock, first pass | 51 | Quick sums puzzle |
| TriPeaks | 97.0% | Yes 18 face down | 49 | Quick, relaxed chains |
* FreeCell: the first million Microsoft deals, checked by other solvers. The other shares are of the first deals of each game our solver played. Moves are the median of the solver's winning games, and in Golf, Pyramid and TriPeaks every stock card turned counts as one. For Klondike and Spider the figure is card moves alone, without turns of the stock or deals, and for Klondike turning one card it is an average.
How often a deal can be won
The share of deals that can be won tells you what kind of game you are choosing, even here, where you only get the winnable ones. Where almost every deal comes out, as in FreeCell (99.999%), Eight Off (99.9%) and TriPeaks (97.0%), the cards rarely beat you, and a loss is a line you did not find. Where few do, as in Golf (26.1%, about one deal in four), the cards hold most of the power, and a winnable deal is still easy to lose.
The numbers for Golf, TriPeaks, Baker's Game and Eight Off are exact: we tried every position each missing deal can reach, and none was a win. FreeCell's comes from other solvers, which went through the first million Microsoft deals and found eight that cannot be won. The rest are floors. Our solver gives up after a set number of positions, and giving up proves nothing. The published study by Charlie Blake and Ian Gent found 90.5% of Klondike deals winnable turning one card and 81.9% turning three, 89.3% for Seahaven Towers, and almost every Spider deal, even with four suits. Pyramid is a close floor: at most 66.7% of its deals can be won. How many games can be won, game by game.
One more caveat. "Can be won" means with every card known. The solver sees the face-down cards and the order of the stock; you do not. That is why what you can see matters as much as the odds.
What you can see
Four games deal all 52 cards face up: FreeCell, Baker's Game, Seahaven Towers and Eight Off. What the solver saw, you see. If you lose, there was a line you missed, and Undo lets you look for it. The FreeCell page puts it plainly: the game is almost entirely skill.
The other eight hide something. Klondike starts with 21 of its 52 cards face down, Spider with 44 of its 104, and TriPeaks with 18 of the 28 in its peaks, each with a stock you cannot see into. Golf and Pyramid deal the table face up and hide only the order of the stock. In Pyramid even that lasts one pass: the stock comes round three times in the same order, so after the first pass nothing is hidden.
Hidden cards bring luck into it. A sensible move can bury the card you needed, and you find out later. Every game here lets Undo take back a move or a turned stock card, so you can look and go back. Whether that is fair is up to you.
How long a win takes
The solver writes down every move of every game it wins. It looks for any way through, not the shortest, so a careful player can often do better, but the figures rank the games well.
The shortest wins are in the face-up games with room to spare: a median of 34 moves in Eight Off, 35 in Seahaven Towers and 38 in Baker's Game. FreeCell takes 59. TriPeaks (49), Golf (51) and Pyramid (51) are short as well, even though every stock card turned counts as a move: a typical TriPeaks win is the 28 peak cards and 21 stock cards.
Klondike is longer than its number looks. Turning one card, the solver's wins averaged 84 card moves plus about 90 turns of the stock. Turning three, a median of 85 card moves plus about 56 turns of the stock. Spider is the long game: a median of 108 card moves with one suit, 141 with two and 208 with four, before counting the five deals. With four suits most of the work comes at the end: in 276 of the solver's first 500 wins, not one run was complete when the last row was dealt.
How much the first layout tells you
In some games you can read your chances before the first move. In others the layout says almost nothing. These are the largest gaps the game pages found, in the share of deals won:
- Golf: with six or fewer Aces, Queens and Kings in the columns, 47.5% of deals can be won; with ten or more, 10.2%.
- Pyramid: a card that covers its own partner, directly or further down, can never pair with it. With 9 or fewer such pairs the solver won 94.0% of deals; with 19 or more, 11.6%.
- Baker's Game: 86.7% with 8 cards or fewer lying on the four Aces, 60.4% with 15 or more.
- Seahaven Towers: 98.2% when both cards in the free cells can leave at once, 82.3% when neither can.
- Klondike Turn 3: 59.3% with three Kings face up, against 73.6% with none.
- Spider 4 Suits: 51.0% when three or more face-up cards can go on their own suit, 41.5% when none can.
Klondike turning one card and Spider with one suit barely respond to what you can see. In turn one, the largest gap is about six points, for two Aces buried deep in the long columns; in one-suit Spider, face-up Aces and Kings move the result by a point or so. In FreeCell, Eight Off and TriPeaks almost every deal comes out whatever the layout; even the worst TriPeaks openings can be won nine times in ten. There the layout tells you more about how hard a deal will be. In FreeCell, deals with 17 or more cards on the Aces were hard for the solver more than three times as often as deals with 8 or fewer.
Luck and skill
FreeCell and Eight Off are as close to pure skill as solitaire gets: every card in view, and almost every deal winnable. Baker's Game and Seahaven Towers are skill too, with less room for error, since every card but a King has a single home in the columns.
Golf is the other end. We tested simple players that cannot see the stock on every winnable Golf deal. Playing the first card that fits cleared 43 of them. Planning the longest run, taking from the tallest columns and playing Kings and Aces the moment they fit raised that to 334, about one winnable deal in sixteen. Skill counts, then, but the stock order counts more.
Klondike, Spider, Pyramid and TriPeaks sit in between. Hidden cards bring some luck, but habits pay: turn face-down cards over first, keep an empty column for when it counts, and count the cards still to come. In TriPeaks the luck is mild, because a chain rarely breaks for good: Aces and Kings join up, so every rank has two neighbours.
What each game is good for
A quick break
TriPeaks is the easiest game here to finish: 97.0% of deals can be won, and a win takes about 49 moves. Pyramid is as short, a few minutes a game, and asks you to add rather than build. For a quick game with nothing hidden, try Eight Off or Seahaven Towers, the two shortest wins on the site.
A long think
FreeCell is the thinking game: every card face up, almost every deal winnable, and every loss yours to put right. Baker's Game asks the same with stricter building. Four-suit Spider is the longest by far, and rewards slow play over two hundred moves.
Learning
Klondike turning one card is the game most people simply call Solitaire, and its layout barely changes the odds, so a poor start is rarely a reason to quit. One-suit Spider is the gentle way into Spider: any card fits on any card one rank higher, and every build joins a run. FreeCell is the base of its family; once you know how runs move there, the other three each change a rule or two.
A challenge
Golf has the worst odds: only about one deal in four can be cleared at all, and even on those, a player who cannot see the stock rarely wins. Four-suit Spider is hard even for our solver, which won 46.5% within its limit. Klondike turning three cards hides two stock cards in three on every pass, and Baker's Game is the strictest of the face-up games.
If you want...
- a short, relaxed game: TriPeaks.
- a quick puzzle with nothing hidden: Eight Off.
- the game you already know: Klondike, turning one card.
- that game with more bite: Klondike Turn 3.
- a long game to settle into: Spider with one suit, then two.
- to plan every move: FreeCell.
- FreeCell to fight back: Baker's Game or Seahaven Towers.
- sums instead of suits: Pyramid.
- the hardest odds on the site: Golf.
- the longest test: Spider 4 Suits.
Whichever you choose, the deal can be won, and Undo, Restart and Hint are there when it goes wrong.
Sources
The published figures come from Charlie Blake and Ian Gent, The Winnability of Klondike Solitaire and Many Other Patience Games. All the other numbers are our own, from the solver's games described on each game's page.