How to play Eight Off
Eight Off deals the whole pack face up, as FreeCell does, and changes three rules: you build by suit, only a King may fill an empty column, and there are eight free cells, half of them full from the start. The extra room more than makes up for the stricter rules: this is the game our solver wins most often, and every game dealt here is one it has won. New to this family of games? Start with FreeCell.
What Eight Off changes
Eight columns of six take 48 cards, and the last four cards dealt go into the first, third, fifth and seventh free cells, so the game starts with four cells taken and four free. The foundations stand in a column of their own on the right.
In the columns you build down in the same suit: only the 7 of hearts can go on the 8 of hearts. In FreeCell a card has two possible places in the columns, the two cards of the other colour one rank higher. Here it has one.
An empty column takes only a King, alone or with the cards built on it, so empty columns no longer help you carry runs: you can move one card more at once than you have free cells. With four cells free you can move five cards; with all eight full, one. In FreeCell each empty column doubles that number, as the FreeCell page explains.
Why almost every deal can be won
Building by suit is a hard rule. Baker's Game uses it with four cells and lets any card into an empty column, and our solver won only 74.9% of its deals. Seahaven Towers builds by suit with Kings-only spaces, ten columns and four cells: 88.5%. Eight Off has both strict rules and still came out 99.86% of the time. What it adds is room.
The published study by Charlie Blake and Ian Gent, which measured many patience games the same way, put Eight Off at 99.9% winnable and Baker's Game at 75.1%. The lesson is that free space matters more than the rule for building: four more cells turn a game lost one time in four into one almost never lost. Only FreeCell, with its looser rule, comes out more often.
The rules in brief
- 48 cards in eight columns of six, all face up; the other four start in alternate cells of the eight.
- Foundations build up by suit from Ace to King; columns build down in the same suit.
- Each free cell holds one card, any card.
- Only a King may go into an empty column, alone or with the cards built on it.
- A run of one suit moves together, up to one card more than there are free cells.
- Move all 52 cards to the foundations to win.
How to play here
Tap or click a card and it goes to the best place: its foundation, otherwise onto the next higher card of its suit, otherwise into an empty column if it is a King, otherwise into a free cell. Tap a card inside a run and the cards on it move too. Since a tap will use a cell when nothing better fits, drag the card when you want it somewhere else.
When you build by suit, a card on its foundation is never needed again, so every card that can go up goes up by itself; drag one off its foundation to take it back. Undo takes back any number of moves, Restart deals the same game again, and Hint shows a move on a way to win, or offers to take you back to the newest position that has one.
Strategy for Eight Off
- Plan with four cells, not eight. The cards dealt into the cells rarely leave early: in the solver's games the last of them left after a median of 27 moves, in games of 34.
- Mind the cell trap. A card in a cell can leave only for its foundation, the next higher card of its suit, or, if it is a King, an empty column. Fill the cells with cards that have none of these in sight and you are stuck, moving one card at a time and only onto its own suit. The solver filled all eight in every one of its 500 games, so full cells are not a mistake in themselves; but before you fill the last two, know which card leaves first.
- Dig out the Aces at the bottom. An Ace dealt first into a column has five cards on it, and nothing else in the deal marks out the impossible games as clearly.
- Free higher cards lying on lower ones of their suit. If the 9 of hearts lies above the 7 of hearts, the 7 cannot go up until the 9 has moved, and the 9 has only two places: the 10 of hearts or a cell.
- Empty a column, then choose the King. A King lying on other cards can leave only for a cell or an empty column until the rest of its suit is home. Give the space to the King whose Queen and Jack are free, or whose suit fills your cells: there it never needs to move again.
- Think twice before parking a King. In a cell it can leave only for an empty column or, last of its suit, its foundation. A parked Queen leaves as soon as its King is uncovered.
- Build runs where they will stay. With free cells plus one as the limit, long runs are hard to move: in four games out of five the solver never moved more than three cards at once. Build them on a King in a column of its own, or on one dealt at the bottom of a column.
What the solver's games look like
Our solver looks for any way through, not the shortest, but its games still show what Eight Off asks. These are its solutions to the first 500 deals it won, counting moves as the game does.
| In the solver's games | Result |
|---|---|
| Moves in the median game (shortest and longest) | 34 (13 and 71) |
| Moves that put a card in a free cell | 49% |
| Games in which all eight cells were full at some point | 500 of 500 |
| Moves made with all eight cells full | 35% |
| Cells in use on the average move, median game | 6.7 of 8 |
| Moves before the first empty column, median | 9 |
| Kings moved into an empty column, median game | 2 |
| Games won without using an empty column | 23 of 500 |
| Games won after trying at most 100 positions | 335 of 500 |
The cells are a workspace, not a reserve: every second move puts a card in one. And Eight Off is easy for a solver: two deals in three came out after it had looked at no more than 100 positions, and only 4 of 500 needed more than 10,000.
What the deal tells you
Only 71 of the first 50,000 deals cannot be won, as the next section explains, but the Aces show a clear pattern.
| In the deal | Cannot be won |
|---|---|
| No Ace at the bottom of a column | 10 of 24,989 |
| One Ace at the bottom | 35 of 19,663 |
| Two Aces at the bottom | 17 of 4,867 |
| Three or four Aces at the bottom | 9 of 481 |
| An Ace in the cells | 0 of 14,248 |
| No card goes up before the first move | 55 of 16,757 |
| At least one card goes up at once | 16 of 33,243 |
Three or four Aces at the bottom make a deal nearly fifty times as likely to be impossible as none, though 98% of such deals can still be won. Kings make no difference: the impossible deals had 3.06 Kings with cards beneath them on average, the others 3.08.
The numbers
Our solver played the first 50,000 deals and won 49,917 of them. The game replayed every solution move by move to confirm it. The first deal the solver did not win was number 465; it never missed two in a row, and its longest run of wins was 2,372 deals.
The solver gives up after 200,000 positions, and giving up proves nothing. So we went back to the 83 deals it missed with a simpler program that tries every legal move from every position it reaches. For 71 it ran out of positions without finding a win: those deals cannot be won by anyone. Deal 465 leads to fewer than 15,000 different positions, and none of them is a win. The other 12, among them 7670 and 33085, can be won after all; the game replayed a way through each, and they are on the list too. So exactly 49,929 of the first 50,000 deals can be won, 99.86%, in line with the published 99.9%, and New game deals only from that list. The numbers for every game.
Game numbers
Every game has a number, and the same number always deals the same cards. Add it to the address, for example #1, to play or share a game. If you type one of the 71 numbers that cannot be won, such as 465, the game says so and deals a winnable game instead.
Frequently asked questions
Why do four cards start in the free cells?
Because eight columns of six hold 48 cards. The four left over go into the first, third, fifth and seventh cells, so you start with four free cells, as many as in FreeCell.
Can I put any card in an empty column?
No, only a King, alone or with the cards built on it. Any other card has to wait in a free cell until the card it belongs on comes free.
How many cards can I move at once with eight cells?
One more than the number of free cells: five with four cells free, one with all eight full. Empty columns do not add to this, because only a King may go into one, so they cannot hold the cards of a run along the way.
Is Eight Off easy?
It is the game our solver wins most often: 99.86% of the first 50,000 deals, in a median of 34 moves. But each card has only one place to go in the columns, so careless use of the cells can still leave you without a move.
Can every deal be won?
Almost. Of the first 50,000 deals, 71 cannot be won: a program that tried every position each of them can reach found no way through. That is about one deal in 700, in line with the 99.9% winnable found by Blake and Gent. Those 71 are never dealt here.
Is Eight Off the same as FreeCell with eight cells?
No. Eight Off also builds down by suit instead of in alternating colours, and lets only a King into an empty column. Both rules make it stricter than FreeCell; the extra cells make up for it.
Is game #1 here the same cards as FreeCell game #1?
The same cards in the same order, laid out a little differently. The eight columns of six here are exactly the first six rows of the FreeCell deal with the same number, and the four cards that end the first four FreeCell columns start in the cells instead.